Is Chieftainship a Boon or a Curse? – A Balanced Perspective

- Pupu Zou

Chieftainship can be both a boon and a curse, depending on how it is practised, who benefits, and how it fits into today’s social realities. Here’s a balanced, clear analysis you can use for essays, speeches, or discussions:

When Chieftainship is a Boon

1. Cultural Identity & Continuity
• It preserves traditional customs, lineage, and collective identity.
• Acts as a living link between ancestors and the community.
2. Conflict Resolution & Social Order
• Chiefs traditionally settle disputes quickly and cheaply.
• Their authority can maintain harmony in small, close-knit societies.
3. Custodians of Land & Resources
• Many tribes view land as community property managed by chiefs for collective welfare.
• Helps prevent the fragmentation of land and keeps community assets intact.
4. Leadership During Crises
• Chiefs can mobilise the community rapidly during conflicts, disasters, or social unrest.
5. Community Unity
• A respected chief becomes a unifying figure above politics.

 When Chieftainship Becomes a Curse

1. Hereditary Power Without Accountability
• Leadership based solely on birth can lead to misuse of power.
• No democratic checks and balances.
2. Land Misuse & Exploitation
• In some places, chiefs treat community land as personal property.
• Land disputes, forced evictions, and favouritism may arise.
3. Suppression of the Common Voice
• Ordinary villagers may have limited say in decision-making.
• Youth and women often remain excluded from leadership.
4. Conflict Within Families
• Succession disputes between brothers, cousins, or clans can destabilise the village.
5. Obstruction of Modern Development
• Some chiefs resist change or political reforms to preserve their authority.
• It can slow down democratic participation and modernisation.

 Final View: Not a Boon or a Curse by Itself

Chieftainship is a system, and systems depend on the people who run them.

• A wise and just chief can bring unity, security, and prosperity.
• A self-serving chief can bring division, injustice, and suffering.

In modern times, many communities find the best solution is reforming chieftainship — keeping tradition but adding accountability, transparency, and community participation.

======================